By: John S. Morlu II, CPA
Homeowners Associations (HOAs) hold the vital responsibility of managing their community’s financial resources—from funding everyday operations to planning for future maintenance and repairs. This financial stewardship is the backbone of a well-functioning community, ensuring smooth operations, homeowner satisfaction, and long-term sustainability. But what happens when these carefully managed funds are mishandled?
One of the most critical—and unfortunately common—errors in HOA financial management is commingling funds, meaning the mixing of reserve funds with operating funds. While it may seem like a minor administrative oversight, this practice can have far-reaching consequences.
Commingling funds doesn’t just blur the lines between financial accounts; it disrupts financial transparency, complicates tracking, and in many cases, violates state regulations. Even more troubling, it undermines the trust homeowners place in their board to manage their hard-earned contributions responsibly.
In this article, we’ll explore the ins and outs of commingling funds: why it happens, the legal and financial risks involved, and how HOAs can avoid it entirely. Whether you’re a board member, property manager, or homeowner, understanding this issue is key to safeguarding your community’s financial health and fostering trust within your neighborhood.
What Is Commingling of Funds?
Commingling occurs when funds intended for different purposes—such as reserve funds and operating funds—are combined into a single account. While this might seem convenient, it creates significant challenges, including:
- Difficulty tracking which funds are being used for specific purposes.
- Increased risk of overspending reserve funds on day-to-day operations.
- Non-compliance with state regulations that require strict separation of funds.
The Distinction Between Reserve and Operating Funds
To understand why commingling is problematic, it’s essential to recognize the distinct purposes of these two types of funds:
- Operating Funds: Used for routine, day-to-day expenses like landscaping, utility bills, and administrative costs. These are predictable, recurring costs.
- Reserve Funds: Dedicated to major repairs, replacements, and unforeseen emergencies, such as roof replacements, road resurfacing, or elevator repairs. These funds help the HOA handle large expenses without imposing special assessments on homeowners.
Mixing these funds blurs the lines between short-term and long-term financial responsibilities, making it difficult to plan effectively.
Industry Standards and Legal Requirements
States like California and Florida mandate the segregation of reserve and operating funds to promote financial transparency and accountability. HOAs in these states—and many others—are legally required to maintain separate bank accounts for reserve and operating funds to prevent misuse and ensure compliance with governing documents.
Interesting Tidbit
California Civil Code § 5510 explicitly prohibits HOAs from using reserve funds for operating expenses, except under strict guidelines, while Florida Statute 718.111 requires the board to manage reserve funds as a fiduciary responsibility.
Consequences of Commingling Funds
The consequences of commingling funds can be severe, both financially and legally:
- Loss of Financial Transparency: Homeowners lose confidence in the HOA’s ability to manage their money effectively when they cannot see a clear distinction between reserve and operating expenses.
- Regulatory Violations: Non-compliance with state laws can result in fines, legal actions, or audits by regulatory authorities.
- Inaccurate Financial Reporting: Mixing funds creates confusion in financial statements, making it difficult to assess the HOA’s true financial health.
- Potential for Fraud or Mismanagement: Commingling funds increases the risk of unintentional misuse or deliberate mismanagement, putting the HOA at financial risk.
- Special Assessments: If reserve funds are depleted for operating costs, homeowners may face unexpected special assessments to cover critical repairs or replacements.
How to Avoid Commingling Funds
Proper fund management practices are essential to avoiding the pitfalls of commingling. Below are actionable steps HOAs can take.
1. Maintain Separate Bank Accounts
- Best Practice: Open distinct accounts for reserve funds and operating funds to ensure clear separation.
- Pro Tip: Use accounts with features tailored to the needs of HOAs, such as interest-bearing reserve accounts.
2. Adopt HOA-Specific Accounting Practices
- Track Transactions Separately: Ensure all income and expenses are accurately categorized and recorded under the appropriate fund.
- Use HOA Accounting Software: Leverage software designed for HOAs to simplify fund tracking and generate clear financial reports.
3. Educate the Board and Management
- Training: Provide board members with training on the importance of fund segregation and state-specific legal requirements.
- Regular Updates: Review financial policies annually to stay compliant with changing regulations.
4. Conduct Regular Financial Reviews
- Internal Audits: Periodically review financial practices to ensure funds are appropriately allocated.
- External Audits: Engage independent auditors to provide an objective assessment of the HOA’s financial health.
5. Establish Clear Policies in Governing Documents
- Define Fund Usage: Ensure your governing documents explicitly outline the purpose and limitations of each fund.
- Enforce Accountability: Require board approval for any transfer of funds between accounts, with documentation and justification.
The Benefits of Proper Fund Management
Avoiding commingling of funds brings significant advantages:
- Transparency: Clear separation of funds builds trust among homeowners and demonstrates responsible financial stewardship.
- Compliance: Helps ensure adherence to state laws and reduces the risk of penalties.
- Financial Stability: Protects reserve funds for their intended purpose, ensuring the community is prepared for major expenses.
- Efficient Reporting: Accurate financial statements make it easier to assess the HOA’s financial position and plan for the future.
Interesting Tidbit
Communities with well-managed funds often experience fewer homeowner disputes, as clear financial practices reduce ambiguity and promote trust.
Conclusion: Strengthening HOA Financial Management
Commingling of funds is a preventable mistake that can have far-reaching consequences for an HOA. By maintaining separate accounts, adopting sound accounting practices, and staying compliant with legal requirements, HOAs can preserve financial clarity and stability.
Effective fund management is more than a best practice—it’s a cornerstone of responsible governance that safeguards the HOA’s financial health and builds homeowner confidence. With the right tools, policies, and oversight, your HOA can avoid commingling issues and focus on creating a thriving, well-maintained community.
Author: John S. Morlu II, CPA
John S. Morlu II, CPA, is the CEO and Chief Strategist of JS Morlu, a globally acclaimed public accounting and management consulting powerhouse. With his visionary leadership, JS Morlu has redefined industries, pioneering cutting-edge technologies across B2B, B2C, P2P, and B2G landscapes.
The firm’s groundbreaking innovations include:
• ReckSoft (www.ReckSoft.com): AI-driven reconciliation software revolutionizing financial accuracy and efficiency.
• FinovatePro (www.FinovatePro.com): Advanced cloud accounting solutions empowering businesses to thrive in the digital age.
• Fixaars (www.fixaars.com): A global handyman platform reshaping service delivery and setting new benchmarks in convenience and reliability.
Under his strategic vision, JS Morlu continues to set the gold standard for technological excellence, efficiency, and transformative solutions.